On the Bay at Matanzas to reopen on Fort Myers Beach

On the Bay, formerly known as Matanzas on the Bay, a Fort Myers Beach favorite since the 1970s, is set to reopen soon for the first time since Hurricane Ian.

Known for its views of Matanzas Pass and its fresh-from-the-Gulf menu, On the Bay has been a staple for both locals and visitors. Guests can expect the same charm that has made it a community icon for decades. The restaurant sits right on the water, offering front-row views of passing fishing boats and even the occasional dolphin.

The menu will once again highlight local seafood, including Gulf shrimp and fresh catch dishes, alongside signature items that regulars have missed. But with a new look comes new creations from Chef Jose Rivera.

With live music scheduled every day, On the Bay will bring back its blend of great food, great views, and lively entertainment.

“We’ve completed extensive renovations on the restaurant. On the Bay has always been about more than just dining. It’s a place where people gather, celebrate, and make memories by the water,” said General Manager Eddie Parisi.

Petey’s Upper Deck, the casual upstairs pizza spot, reopened earlier this year and has already welcomed back many familiar faces. The return of On the Bay will complete the experience, with both spaces ready to serve the community once again.

Private party spaces will also be available for groups looking for a waterfront setting to host events, meetings, and celebrations.

The restaurant will share more details soon, but the team’s excitement is clear: On the Bay isready to once again be part of Fort Myers Beach life.